In a move that should surprise few, auto insurance website insure.com has released a list of the most and least expensive cars to insure, a list that has a 10-cylinder super convertible at the top and a four-cylinder minivan at the bottom.
Insure.com released a list of the 20 most and least expensive cars to insure, and we’ll admit something: there aren’t many surprises on them.
For the most part, the least expensive autos to insure were minivans, pickup trucks, or compact utility vehicles: cars like the Honda Odyssey ($1146/year), Toyota Sienna ($1111/year), Ford Escape ($1137/year) and Chevrolet Silverado ($1143/year) topped the list. Worth mentioning is that the adage that “there’s no replacement for displacement” is true, in reverse: in the case of the Sienna, where four-cylinder and V-6 models are available, the four-cylinder models were less expensive to insure. Same for the trucks: while the Silverado V-6 model was one of the 20 least expensive autos, the V-8 models were not.
On the other hand, the most expensive vehicles to insure were a crop of usual, high performance suspects, many with three-digit names: AMG, GT-R, 911, XKR, BMW. Topping the list was the iconic Audi R8 Spyder, which will no doubt hit owners with a 5.2-liter V-10 punch and an average of $3384 in yearly premiums.
On this list, displacement wasn’t always a factor in making cars more or less expensive to insure: a Porsche 911 Turbo Cabriolet is more expensive to insure ($2674/year) than a Mercedes-Benz CL65 AMG Coupe ($2669/year), despite having half the cylinders. The BMW 750 was hit especially hard: all four of the car’s four variants were on the list. The 750i was 20th, at $2430/year; the 750i xDrive cost $2446, putting it at 19th; the ActiveHybrid 750Li clocked in at $2641/year; and the ActiveHybrid 750i, without the long wheelbase, was $2701/year.
Is there a takeaway from this list? Why, of course. If you’re interested in saving quite a lot of money and you’re in the market for a Nissan, put away the plans to buy a GT-R ($2457/year) and buy the Frontier ($1162/year) instead. Granted, if you can afford one of the 20 most expensive cars to insure, we’d assume you have the insurance money handy, so drive safely.
Source: Insure.com
Least Expensive Cars:
Rank | Vehicle | Cyl. | Nat’l annual avg. rate |
1 | Toyota Sienna LE | 4 | $1,111 |
2 | Toyota Sienna | 4 | $1,114 |
3 | Jeep Patriot Sport | 4 | $1,116 |
4 | Jeep Compass Sport | 4 | $1,118 |
5 | GMC Sierra K1500 Regular Cab | 6 | $1,121 |
6 | Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Regular Cab | 6 | $1,125 |
7 | Dodge Grand Caravan SXT | 6 | $1,129 |
8 | Ford![]() |
4 | $1,137 |
9 | Toyota Sienna | 6 | $1,139 |
10 | Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Extended Cab | 6 | $1,143 |
11 | Dodge Journey SXT | 6 | $1,143 |
12 | Honda Odyssey LX | 6 | $1,146 |
13 | Kia Sportage | 4 | $1,151 |
14 | Hyundai Santa Fe GLS | 4 | $1,152 |
15 | Jeep Wrangler Unlimited Sport | 6 | $1,154 |
16 | Nissan Frontier S King Cab | 4 | $1,162 |
17 | Nissan Frontier SV King Cab | 4 | $1,163 |
18 | Hyundai Tucson GL | 4 | $1,166 |
19 | Ford Escape XLT | 4 | $1,167 |
20 | GMC Canyon | 4 | $1,167 |
Most Expensive Cars:
Rank | Vehicle | Cyl. | Nat’l annual avg. rate |
1 | Audi R8 Spyder Quattro Convertible | 10 | $3,384 |
2 | Mercedes CL600 Coupe | 12 | $3,307 |
3 | Mercedes S600 | 12 | $2,948 |
4 | Audi R8 4.2 Quattro Coupe | 8 | $2,903 |
5 | Porsche Panamera Turbo | 8 | $2,738 |
6 | BMW 750i Hybrid![]() |
8 | $2,701 |
7 | Porsche 911 Turbo Convertible | 6 | $2,674 |
8 | Porsche 911 Turbo S Convertible | 6 | $2,674 |
9 | Mercedes CL65 AMG Coupe | 12 | $2,669 |
10 | BMW 750Li Hybrid | 8 | $2,641 |
11 | Mercedes SL63 AMG Convertible | 8 | $2,615 |
12 | Mercedes CL63 AMG Coupe | 8 | $2,613 |
13 | Jaguar XKR Supercharged Convertible | 8 | $2,585 |
14 | Mercedes S63 AMG | 8 | $2,542 |
15 | Mercedes C63 AMG Coupe | 8 | $2,532 |
16 | Audi A8 L Quattro | 12 | $2,513 |
17 | Mercedes SL550 Convertible | 8 | $2,458 |
18 | Nissan GT-R Coupe Turbo | 6 | $2,457 |
19 | BMW 750XI | 8 | $2,446 |
20 | BMW 750i | 8 | $2,430 |